1. Home
  2. Offers and first weeks
  3. Part 7 of 9

Comparing two job offers

Offers and first weeksNovember 19, 20263 min read

A woman reading a printed page beside a colleague at a laptop

Holding two offers at once lets you choose on the terms rather than on timing alone. This article helps you put both offers on one page, weigh what each pays and what each costs you, and manage the deadlines so neither employer is left waiting.

Put both offers on one page

Ask each employer for its offer in writing, then make a table with a row for every term: title, pay rate, pay schedule, exempt or nonexempt status, scheduled hours, start date, location and each benefit with the date it begins. Blank cells show you which questions to send before you decide.

Turn both rates of pay into the same unit. An hourly rate has to be multiplied by the hours you can actually expect, counting overtime only when it is regular rather than occasional, before it compares fairly with a salary. A salary in an exempt role with frequent long weeks can work out to less per hour than it first appears.

Blank cells show you which questions to send before you decide.

Count the benefits and the costs of the job

Benefits can outweigh a gap in pay. Compare what each health plan takes from a paycheck, its deductible and whether your doctors are in its network, using the summary of benefits and coverage each employer provides. Then set the retirement plans side by side, including whether the employer adds to your account and how long vesting takes, along with paid time off and holidays.

Some costs never appear in an offer letter. Add up commute time and the cost of gas, parking or transit, any change in child care that a new schedule forces, required uniforms or tools, and shifts that rotate or fall on weekends. A job closer to home with steady hours can leave you better off than one that pays more on paper.

Weigh what the letters leave out

Think about the manager you met, the training on offer, and the chance to move up. Read each offer for a non-compete or a repayment clause, since rules on non-compete agreements vary by state and can limit your next move. People who work at either employer, or who left recently, can describe what an ordinary week is like.

Write down the two or three things that matter most to you this year, such as a predictable schedule, a health plan for your family or a path into a trade. Score each offer against those first, and let everything else break a tie.

Manage the timing honestly

Offers often arrive days apart. You can ask the first employer for a few more days, and you can tell the second that you hold an offer with a deadline and ask whether it can speed up its decision.

If you use one offer to ask the other employer for better terms, describe it accurately, because the employer may ask to see the letter. Once you decide, accept one offer in writing and decline the other the same day.

Steps to take this week

  • Ask both employers for their offers in writing
  • Build a table with one row for each term
  • Convert both rates of pay to the same unit
  • Add up commute and child care costs for each job
  • Write down your three priorities for this year

Who to ask

The recruiter at each employer, and HR for the plan documents

Compare both offers term by term on one page, count the costs the letters leave out, and decide by what matters most to you.

TagsOffers and first weeksAll articlesLetter builder

Related articles

More from other parts of the job search

View all

Get job search tips

New and updated articles on the part of the job search you choose, by email, and by text if you tick the box.

Email, or text if you chooseSign up