1. Home
  2. Gaps and changes
  3. Part 6 of 7

Fair chance hiring and a past conviction

Gaps and changesNovember 19, 20263 min read

A man thinking as he works at a laptop

Many employers hire people with records, and the law sets some rules on how they decide. This article explains fair chance laws, your rights in a background check and how to talk about a past conviction when the question comes.

What fair chance laws change

Many states and cities have fair chance laws, often called ban the box, that delay questions about criminal records until later in hiring, often after an interview or a conditional offer. Some apply only to public employers, and others cover private employers too. The federal Fair Chance to Compete Act applies the same idea to most federal agencies and contractors.

The EEOC says that refusing everyone with a record can be discrimination in some cases, and it encourages employers to weigh the offense, the time since it happened and the nature of the job. Some jobs are still closed by law to people with certain convictions, such as some work with children or in security, and state licensing boards set their own rules.

Keep those papers ready in one folder.

Your rights when an employer checks

When an employer uses a screening company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires your written permission first. Before turning you down because of the report, the employer must give you a copy and a summary of your rights, so you can correct errors such as a dismissed charge or someone else's record.

Some fair chance laws also require the employer to explain its decision and give you time to respond with evidence of rehabilitation, such as completed programs, steady work since release or letters from a supervisor. Keep those papers ready in one folder.

Clearing or sealing a record

Many states let people seal or expunge some convictions after a waiting period, and some clear certain records automatically. A sealed record usually stays off most background checks, and many states let you leave it off most private job applications. The rules depend on the state and the offense.

A legal aid office, a public defender's office or a reentry program can tell you what applies to your record and help with the paperwork, often at no cost.

Talking about your record

When the question comes, answer it truthfully, because a false answer on an application can cost you the job later even where the conviction would not have. Keep the explanation to a few sentences: what happened, that you took responsibility and what you have done since. An answer such as “I made a serious mistake eight years ago, and since then I have finished a welding program and held steady work” points the conversation forward.

Employers can get free fidelity bonds for workers with records through the Federal Bonding Program, and many can claim the Work Opportunity Tax Credit for hiring people with felony convictions within a set time after conviction or release. American Job Centers can explain both, and mentioning them gives an employer one more reason to say yes.

Steps to take this week

  • Look up your state and city fair chance rules
  • Request a copy of your own record to check it for errors
  • Ask a legal aid office whether your record can be sealed
  • Gather proof of programs completed and steady work
  • Ask an American Job Center about the Federal Bonding Program

Who to ask

A legal aid office or a reentry program in your state

Know which questions an employer may ask and when, answer truthfully and bring proof of what you have done since.

TagsGaps and changesAll articlesLetter builder

Related articles

More from other parts of the job search

View all

Get job search tips

New and updated articles on the part of the job search you choose, by email, and by text if you tick the box.

Email, or text if you chooseSign up